Rekeying Between Tenants: A Simple Checklist

A tenant moved out. Who still has a key? Use this simple checklist to rekey the right locks before the next tenant moves in.

A tenant moves out. They hand back a key or two. But you don't know how many copies they made. You don't know who they gave one to.

That's why most property managers rekey between tenants. It's the simplest way to know the new tenant is the only one with a working key.

Here is a short checklist you can use every time.

What rekeying means

Rekeying changes the small pins inside a lock. The old keys stop working. A new key works. You keep the same lock and handle.

It is usually faster and costs less than putting in new locks. You only need new locks if the old ones are worn out or broken.

Step 1: Get the keys back

Ask for every key on move-out day. Write down how many came back. Check them against how many you handed out.

Even if every key comes back, rekey anyway. A key can be copied in a few minutes.

Step 2: List every lock the tenant could open

It's easy to think only of the front door. Walk the space and write down each lock:

  • Front and back doors
  • Side doors and service doors
  • Inside office doors with locks
  • Storage rooms, closets, and cages
  • Mailbox locks
  • Gates and padlocks

One missed lock is all it takes for an old key to still work.

Step 3: Check how the locks look and work

While the space is empty, test each lock. Does the key turn smooth? Does the door latch? Is anything loose or bent?

The fix: if a lock is worn, sticky, or broken, replace that one. Rekey the rest. There's no reason to pay for all new locks when most are fine.

Step 4: Think about your master key

Many buildings use a master key system. One key opens many doors for the manager. Each tenant's key opens only their own space.

When you rekey a tenant's lock, the new key should still fit your system. That way your master key keeps working, and the new tenant's key only opens their door.

The fix: tell your locksmith you have a master key system before they start. Have your key chart or old key info ready if you have it.

Step 5: Decide how many new keys to make

Hand out only what the new tenant needs. Write down how many you gave and to whom. Keep that list with the lease.

Want to stop extra copies? Ask about restricted keys. They can only be cut by an approved locksmith with your OK. A hardware store can't copy them.

Step 6: Plan it before move-in day

Book the rekey for the gap between tenants. It's easier when the space is empty. And the new tenant gets keys on day one.

If you manage many units, send the list of doors ahead of time. That helps your locksmith bring the right parts.

Quick checklist

  • Collect all keys and count them
  • List every lock in the space
  • Test each lock while it's empty
  • Replace only the worn or broken ones
  • Rekey the rest to fit your master system
  • Cut only the keys the new tenant needs
  • Write down who has what

Need a rekey between tenants?

We do commercial rekeys for property managers across Dallas–Fort Worth. You get the price before we start. If it's not fixed right, we come back free.

Send us a message or call (682) 324-6688. We are open Monday to Friday, 7:30 AM to 6 PM, and we call back the same business day.

Quick answers

Should I rekey even if the tenant returned all keys?

Yes. You can't know if a key was copied. Rekeying makes every old key stop working, so only the new tenant's keys open the door.

Is rekeying cheaper than new locks?

Usually, yes. Rekeying keeps your locks and only changes the pins inside. You only need new locks if the old ones are worn out or broken.

Will rekeying a unit break my master key?

It shouldn't, if your locksmith knows you have a master key system. The new key is made to fit the system, so your master key keeps working.

Got a door problem? Let’s fix it.

Commercial locksmith in Fort Worth, Irving, and all of DFW. Open Monday to Friday, 8 AM to 6 PM.

★★★★★ 5.0 · 364+ Google reviews

Homeowner or one quick fix? Get a free quote →

Call Now Get a Quote